Summary of an article published on The Web Scraping Club on 2025-06-01 (free to read). Read the full article
Without proxies, scraping a protected target at scale does not work. Datacenter IPs get flagged fast, so on hard targets the real choice is between residential and mobile proxies. They differ in trust, pool size, speed, reliability and price, and the wrong pick means either wasted budget or blocks.
I first sort proxies by protocol, visibility, IP behavior and IP origin, so the terms are clear. Then I compare residential and mobile proxies head to head on six criteria and turn that into selection rules based on target, budget, scale, geo-targeting and session needs. To check it in practice, I ran one residential and one mobile IP from the same provider through Scamalytics. I also wrote a Python script with requests that hits the same target three times: with no proxy, with a residential proxy and with a mobile one.
What’s inside
- Why an IP shared by many users through CGNAT is still trusted by anti-bot systems
- Where ISP proxies sit between datacenter and residential IPs, and why they are static IPs often hosted in data centers
- Why speed varies for both types: signal and network load on mobile, peer-to-peer home connections on residential
- How session persistence works differently on residential proxies and on mobile ones tied to a device or SIM
In the full article: Scamalytics screenshots for both IPs, the Python test script with its install step, and the way to read its output.